You’ve imagined the family gathering around a blazing fire during the holidays. Maybe you’ve even pictured the stockings hung by the fireplace. But have you given much thought to the mantel itself? Do you want a traditional full surround mantel? Or a simple mantel shelf? What about the material of the mantel?
Selecting the right mantel material involves considering various factors such as style, durability, maintenance, budget, and compatibility with your fireplace and the surrounding décor. Here's a step-by-step guide to help you pick the right mantel material.
Ready for a Fireplace Mantel? What Material?
- Wood
- Cast Stone
- Metal
- Concrete
- Marble
- Natural Stone
Style and Aesthetic Appeal
Determine the style and look you want for your mantel. Consider the existing décor of the room. Mantels come in various materials like wood, stone, marble, metal, or a combination of these. Each material has its unique aesthetic appeal, from rustic to modern, traditional to contemporary.
Durability and Maintenance
Evaluate the durability and maintenance requirements of different materials. For example:
Wood: Classic and versatile but might require more maintenance like refinishing or polishing.
Stone: Durable and low maintenance but can be more expensive.
Cast Stone: hollow in the center so they're lightweight, and generally easier to care for than stone.
Marble: Elegant and luxurious but can be prone to staining if not sealed properly.
Metal: Modern and sleek, often low maintenance but might show scratches or dents.
Concrete: noncombustible, modern look, should be resealed regularly.
Compatibility with Fireplace
Ensure the chosen material complements your fireplace. The mantel should fit well with the size, style, and aesthetics of the fireplace without overpowering or conflicting with its design.
Budget Consideration
Set a budget for your mantel. Some materials might be more costly than others due to their quality, rarity, or craftsmanship.
Installation
Consider ease of installation. Some materials may require specialized installation techniques or professionals to ensure proper fitting and safety.
Go to Our Installation Library
Local Building Codes
Check local building codes and regulations, especially regarding combustible materials near fireplaces. Some materials may have restrictions based on fire safety codes.
Personal Preferences
Your personal preferences matter. If you have a strong inclination towards a particular material or style, it might be the best choice for you, provided it aligns with other practical considerations.
Environmental Impact
Consider the environmental impact of your choice. Some materials may be more sustainable or eco-friendly than others. For example, reclaimed wood or recycled materials might align better with eco-conscious values.
Seek Advice
If you're unsure, consult with interior designers, contractors, or professionals who can provide insights and suggestions based on your preferences and needs.
Top Picks
Wood
Vail Wood Mantel Shelf: One of our most popular wood mantel shelves, this clean-lined modern look breathes life into your fireplace and your space’s design.
Lenwood Mantel: A classic wood mantel look that frames your fireplace with just the right amount of visual interest. Available in white, black, or unfinished.
Cast Stone
Melrose Classic Series: Just like natural stone, this composite mantel has variations in color and texture that captures the look and feel of a classic stone mantel without the weight of stone. Available in custom sizes. Select optional surround, facing, hearth, and over-mantel for the full effect.
Asher Fireplace Mantel: Both sophisticated and stylish, this modern styled mantel comes in various stone look-alikes like marble, limestone, slate, etc.
Concrete
Ashcroft Concrete Mantel Shelf: A wood-look concrete with authentic grain and end texture that will not warp, crack, or degrade like wood. Can be used outdoors or indoors.
Everett Concrete Mantel Shelf: contemporary and clean, this non-combustible mantel doesn’t need the clearance of other mantels. Hollow construction for lightweight installation.
Metal
Tucker Black Metal Mantel Shelf: rugged in design but has the durability of powder coated steel. The clean, minimalist design is great for all design styles.
Mission Mantel Shelf: Handcrafted by skilled blacksmiths, this unique, old-world style mantel has no clearance restrictions. Hidden storage inside the mantel offers an extra perk.
Marble & Stone
Canterbury Marble Mantel: Ornate carved detailing and classic white marble for a dramatic mantel and fireplace. Available in limestone, gray marble and Volakas marble.
Chateau Marble Mantel: Clean and simple yet elegant, this marble or limestone mantel makes a grand centerpiece for your home.